Horror Nights Wish List - Orlando (2025)

Jake S said:

yeah and Brian’s point is that we’re not discussing whether or not FNAF is “horror.” it’s definitely horror. it’s just horror that is consumed, to a large degree, by young people.

Click to expand...

I guess my point is that it kind of belongs in hhn if we get stuff like Harry Potter and Weeknd. the animatronics might be cutesy. but universal would make them very scary.
if they can make the Weeknd stuff scary I'm sure that five nights would be very scary

Jake S said:

yeah and Brian’s point is that we’re not discussing whether or not FNAF is “horror.” it’s definitely horror. it’s just horror that is consumed, to a large degree, by young people.

Click to expand...

Which really opens up a larger discussion, as there's many big horror properties out there that are more mature (DbD, Resident Evil, Silent Hill just to name a few) that millions of kids way too young for them have started watching videos of and getting into, when they really shouldn't be.

Lucky Planet said:

I guess my point is that it kind of belongs in hhn if we get stuff like Harry Potter and Weeknd. the animatronics might be cutesy. but universal would make them very scary.
if they can make the Weeknd stuff scary I'm sure that five nights would be very scary

Click to expand...

Take the loss bub

Lucky Planet said:

I guess my point is that it kind of belongs in hhn if we get stuff like Harry Potter and Weeknd. the animatronics might be cutesy. but universal would make them very scary.
if they can make the Weeknd stuff scary I'm sure that five nights would be very scary

Click to expand...

See Also

Is The Xenomorph the most disappointing licensed chapter?Improvements for DBD (please read everything carefully)Dead by Daylight x Castlevania Version 8.2.0 PTB Patch Notes Revealed, Crossover With Five Nights at Freddy's AnnouncedLegion, Freddy and Myers...

you are literally arguing with nobody. please stop.

Scooby-Doo is a more “mature” IP than Five Nights.

Both are perfectly appropriate for HHN and would very likely make strong houses.

(The Scooby-Doo house would be better).

Casper Gutman said:

Scooby-Doo is a more “mature” IP than Five Nights.

Both are perfectly appropriate for HHN and would very likely make strong houses.

Click to expand...

Eh, I don't think that's really an apt comparison. Scooby-Doo is certainly a spooky Halloween-adjacent property, but it has pretty much always been comedic and lighthearted. The original Five Nights at Freddy's games were firmly horror, setting out directly to frighten the player with jump scares and startling audio queues. When I was younger, I was very scared of FNaF, but I've felt that way about Scooby-Doo at any point in my life.

Casper Gutman said:

Scooby-Doo is a more “mature” IP than Five Nights.

Both are perfectly appropriate for HHN and would very likely make strong houses.

(The Scooby-Doo house would be better).

Click to expand...

could be based on the movies l since those had monsters and stuff.

Casper Gutman said:

Scooby-Doo is a more “mature” IP than Five Nights.

Both are perfectly appropriate for HHN and would very likely make strong houses.

(The Scooby-Doo house would be better).

Click to expand...

When FNAF started it was totally a "grim dark" property. #ChangeMyMind

OhHaiInternet95 said:

When FNAF started it was totally a "grim dark" property. #ChangeMyMind

Click to expand...

what do you mean

Casper Gutman said:

Scooby-Doo is a more “mature” IP than Five Nights.

Both are perfectly appropriate for HHN and would very likely make strong houses.

(The Scooby-Doo house would be better).

Click to expand...

imma respectfully say this is cap lol. first games game over has you stuffed into a suit with your teeth and eyes bursting through the suit, 3 has a rotting decaying corpse which you see a ton in detail inside of an animatronic, along with the person dying inside of the suit in a painful death, 4th has a kids head crushed in an animatronics jaws putting him in a coma, and Sister Location has two bodies hung up in what looks like nooses, and your main characters insides being scooped out so an animatronic can wear you as a skin suit.

I love both IPs, but saying Scooby Doo is more mature then FNAF is insane lol

Me reading this thread today

hhnlover said:

imma respectfully say this is cap lol. first games game over has you stuffed into a suit with your teeth and eyes bursting through the suit, 3 has a rotting decaying corpse which you see a ton in detail inside of an animatronic, along with the person dying inside of the suit in a painful death, 4th has a kids head crushed in an animatronics jaws putting him in a coma, and Sister Location has two bodies hung up in what looks like nooses, and your main characters insides being scooped out so an animatronic can wear you as a skin suit.

I love both IPs, but saying Scooby Doo is more mature then FNAF is insane lol

Click to expand...

I’m pretty sure we don’t agree on what “mature” means. In terms of thematic depth, emotional resonance, writing quality, character development, evocation of mood they’re pretty equivalent- and Scooby doesn’t have any pretenses of being “super serious for real.”

hhnlover said:

imma respectfully say this is cap lol. first games game over has you stuffed into a suit with your teeth and eyes bursting through the suit, 3 has a rotting decaying corpse which you see a ton in detail inside of an animatronic, along with the person dying inside of the suit in a painful death, 4th has a kids head crushed in an animatronics jaws putting him in a coma, and Sister Location has two bodies hung up in what looks like nooses, and your main characters insides being scooped out so an animatronic can wear you as a skin suit.

I love both IPs, but saying Scooby Doo is more mature then FNAF is insane lol

Click to expand...

like Simpsons treehouse of horror has a lot of messed up stuff.

Screw it, let's just do Peter Pan. But Idk, make them vampires or something. That could work.

mccgavin said:

Eh, I don't think that's really an apt comparison. Scooby-Doo is certainly a spooky Halloween-adjacent property, but it has pretty much always been comedic and lighthearted. The original Five Nights at Freddy's games were firmly horror,...

Click to expand...

Ghostbusters, Beetlejuice and KKfOS show it's not strictly a comedy/humor divide. It's more the age of the intended audience. (And yeah, the mercenary tendency in the 80s to turn literally any IP into a cartoon -- Rambo springs to mind, Kenner released toys from an Alien cartoon that thankfully never made screens -- often clouds the issue.)

SeventyOne said:

Screw it, let's just do Peter Pan. But Idk, make them vampires or something. That could work.

Click to expand...

it's funny that some people been begging for this ( including me lol )

( that's the only gif I found of the movie, their reactions are not what I meant lol. just wanted a movie gif. )

SeventyOne said:

Ghostbusters, Beetlejuice and KKfOS show it's not strictly a comedy/humor divide. It's more the age of the intended audience. (And yeah, the mercenary tendency in the 80s to turn literally any IP into a cartoon -- Rambo springs to mind, Kenner released toys from an Alien cartoon that thankfully never made screens -- often clouds the issue.)

Click to expand...

My point wasn't that comedy/horror-adjacent properties do not belong at the event, it's simply that I do not believe that Five Nights at Freddy's falls under that genre, and that it would somehow inhibit it from being featured at the event. Five Nights at Freddy's demographic is not quite the same as many of the other properties that have been featured at the event, but it certainly wouldn't the biggest departure from "core horror" that HHN has ever seen.

mccgavin said:

My point wasn't that comedy/horror-adjacent properties do not belong at the event, it's simply that I do not believe that Five Nights at Freddy's falls under that genre, and that it would somehow inhibit it from being featured at the event. Five Nights at Freddy's demographic is not quite the same as many of the other properties that have been featured at the event, but it certainly wouldn't the biggest departure from "core horror" that HHN has ever seen.

Click to expand...

technically I can see the idea that the fan base for Freddy's is too young or something like that. I can see that the games are for younger fans. I can see that point. I don't even deny that observation. I see it, I see the case.
but if anything, stranger things already broke that barrier, the audience for stranger things and the audience for Freddy's probably overlaps alot. ( not the properties but the fan base of Freddy's probably like stranger things)
I think that stranger things changed stuff. you can feel the change. ( maybe Freddy's doesn't belong in the park, but the younger audiences came with st)